The specter, whose identity is something of a mystery, is almost certainly the same woman who appears in a group photograph taken in front of the building sometime before 1900. In it she wears the black dress and is holding a baby. Countless witnesses have identified her as the ghost of The Lofts.
Some years this hotel is included on the Columbus Landmarks Foundation's ghost tours. What follows is Carole Mauro's story, told to me after she took the tour in 2006.
The general manager of the hotel split our group of 20 into two groups
because we couldn't all fit in the stairwell at the same time. I was
the first person in the second group. She took the first group into the
stairwell advising them to look at the red pipe on the landing between
the two floors and we might see the ghost out of the corner of our eye. She said that the ghost disappeared if you looked at her straight on. This
was my third ghost tour in eight days and I was half listening. The first group entered and returned from the stairwell without event. It is the second group's turn and I happened to be closest to the door. The general manager says, remember to look at the red pipe on the landing.
I walk through the door and turn left to begin climbing the metal
stairs. I find the red pipe in the corner of the landing and see someone dressed in a long black dress with lace up boots about half way the second flight. I think to myself there must be an employee using the steps and run up the steps after them to confirm what I see. When I turn the corner of the
steps on the landing, there is nothing on the next flight of steps. There is
no noise of boots running up the metal steps, no dooring swinging shut
behind anyone leaving the stairwell. Nothing. I turn to my friend who was
directly behind me on the steps and ask her if she saw "that." She said she
saw a black boot on the steps. I could have convinced myself that I saw
something only because I wanted to, but my friend saw it too.
I was getting a little freaked out in the stairwell and the general
manager called up for us to meet the rest of the group on the second floor of
the hotel. We emerge from the stairs and she asks the group if anyone saw
anything. My friend points to me. The general manager asks me what I
saw and I described a figure dressed in a long black dress with lace up
boots holding something in front of her. She asks me to follow her around
the elevator shaft to look at one of the many prints that the Columbus
Metropolitan Library has donated to the hotel. She shows me a group
picture of many people standing in front of the building before 1900. She asks me to pick out the person I saw on the stairs. I pointed to a woman in
the front row wearing a black dress, holding a baby. The general manager
says that that is the same woman that she has seen between 10-15 times in
the stairwell.
I
have been looking for about five years just as a hobby, but Saturday night was the first time in my life that I have seen a ghost.